Murder Forensics, what are they and who is responsible for them?
In an age of neverending reality crime shows on TV, it would be easy to think we already know how forensic science works. In some cases this might be true, but the reality of an active murder investigation is not box-office and the basics of the scientific work far more complex than the TV would have you believe. From pathologists to neuropathologists, to toxicologists we set out here a brief guide by our specialist murder lawyers to the role of expert witnesses and their importance to both the prosecution and defence case.
The Pathologist
In all cases in which a death is treated as suspicious, the body will be examined by a forensic pathologist. His or her goal is to find out the cause of death, the time of death if unknown, any other information which may be of use in determining the circumstances of the death - and if the death was violent they will look at the possible use of any weapons and details about the attacker such as their height and weight. The pathologist will also look for anything on the body which could identify the attacker, such as DNA material from blood, semen, saliva or skin.
Experienced murder lawyers will also be aware that the pathologist will be able to obtain samples taken from the body to be examined under a microscope. This process is called histology, or histopathology. The outcome of this process may be that more is known about how the death happened, whether it is as a result of organ failure, loss of blood, or even the possibility of poisoning.
The second post mortem
If the murder lawyers are retained by the suspect early enough, they should consider bringing in a defence pathologist to review any of the findings of the police or Crown pathologist. This is not just a case of going through the pathologist's report. Permission will usually need to be obtained from the coroner, but time is of the essence because the family of the deceased will usually want the body returned to them quickly for burial or cremation.
The goal of the second post mortem is for the defence pathologist to check the conclusions of the police pathologist and to consider whether any alternative explanations are possible. Because the defence pathologist will not have prior knowledge of the case, it is important that the defence murder lawyers ask that certain possibilities which may be of assistance are explored by the expert. It is not unusual for somebody from the defence team to attend the second post mortem so that a first-hand view of the situation can be taken by the murder lawyer.
Neuropathologists and the brain
In cases where there has been a head injury or if there is any doubt about cause of death, the brain of the deceased will be sent by the police's pathologist to a neuropathologist, who is a specialist in the analysis of brains. This expert will look at whether the death or cause of death was influenced by the existence of any diseases or underlying conditions suffered by the deceased, and for any chemical clues as to the circumstances of the death. It is vital that specialist murder lawyers are able to consider and understand this evidence.
The results of a neuropathology report can be particularly important in cases involving suffocation, head injuries caused by beating or stamping, and infant death cases. For this reason, the murder solicitors should always try to instruct a neuropathologist for the defence where the need arises. There have sadly been too many examples in recent years of police-instructed neuropathologists giving evidence leading to wrongful murder convictions. These cases are a constant reminder to all murder lawyers to never just accept the prosecution evidence at face value.
Toxicologists
Toxicologists in murder cases can be of great importance. Their job is to look at the effects of any chemicals on the body. The defence murder lawyers should always consider instructing their own toxicologist to look for the presence of any chemicals on the body, should it be appropriate. These chemicals could include alcohol or illegal drugs. If such things are found it could have a bearing on the circumstances of the death, either as a potential cause or because they could have affected the deceased's behaviour which supports what the client says about what happened, which may be especially important in a case where the issue is self-defence.
Nick Ives
Associate Director
Nick is a Solicitor in our London office, and defends clients throughout the South East and nationally. He is experienced in Fraud, Serious Crime and Sexual Offences. He was the COO of an international charity before joining the firm.
Get a free case review
What do I get and how does it work?
Free time with a lawyer
You get dedicated time with one of our specialist criminal solicitors on the phone or in person, with no obligation, for free.
Non-judgmental listening
When we’re talking with you, we promise to be always non-judgmental and sensitive to what you’re going through.
Expert opinion
Our criminal solicitors start by asking you questions so we can understand what’s going on, and we listen carefully to what you tell us.
How long will my free case review last?
Less serious cases
In some cases which are less serious or complex, it may be ten or twenty minutes on the phone.
Serious cases
In more serious or difficult situations we may need an hour or two in person to go through things with you properly.
Unable to help
If it’s obvious straight away that we wouldn’t be able to help, we’ll tell you straight away and point you in the right direction to find lawyers who can help. We don’t offer a free case review if you aren’t considering hiring a lawyer in your case.
No-tricks fixed-fee pricing
We can usually offer a fixed fee instalment plan so you can plan for the expense, and so you can fund your case in stages while it is continuing.
Contact information
Call us
0161 794 0088
Office openings
Monday - Thursday: 9:00 - 17:30
Friday: 9:00 - 17:00
Send us a confidential message
We'll get back to you as soon as possible. We are happy to speak to you if you have a query, and either have a free consultation on the phone or in person if necessary.