We have included a brief guide on this area of law and case studies of previous cases we have fought for anyone who wishes to know more about what the issues are in such cases.
Case Study 1
Our client was one of four men accused of beating up a man outside a pub in Radcliffe after closing time. The victim was in a coma for several weeks, and suffered brain damage. All of the co-defendants were represented by other local solicitors. All of them were found guilty and received prison sentences for GBH.
Verdict | Not Guilty
Case study 2
Our clients were two local businessmen who were accused of attacking a taxi driver after an argument over the fare. They were both company directors with responsibility for a large number of employees, and a criminal record would have meant that they would have been unable to run their businesses effectively. One was an estate agent, and would have lost his business immediately. The other had contracts with major government institutions which would have been cancelled if he was convicted.
We undertook a complete background check of the alleged victim in the case, checked CCTV footage of the scene held by local shop owners, and spent dozens of hours preparing the case in a way that meant that every avenue of enquiry had been followed up. We also picked through every piece of evidence against our clients in consultation with each of them.
Finally, and unusually for a Magistrates Court Case, we were able to organise Mary Monson's diary so that she could act in the trial for our clients. Within 4 hours of the first day of the trial, Mary Monson made an application to have the case thrown out, and the Magistrates duly obliged.
Verdict | Not Guilty - court ordered £12,000 costs to be paid back to our clients.
GBH (Grievous Bodily Harm Section 18 and Section 20 Assault).
To be convicted of this offence, the defendant must be proved to have committed really serious harm, or wounded another person (for example by stabbing with a knife). However, the damage must be intended. If the intention of the defendant was to only cause some pain or harm, but not "really serious harm", then the offence committed is Section 20 Assault - a less serious version of GBH, also called "wounding without intent". So a defendant who has kicked somebody else and broken their ribs, could be guilty of Section 20 Assault if they did not specifically want to cause that damage, but Section 18 Assault if they actually intended that damage.
Whether an offence is Section 18 or Section 20 is important when it comes to sentence. Section 20 Assault has a maximum sentence of 5 years imprisonment, and can even be dealt with in the Magistrates Court, although it is quite rare that the magistrates will prevent it from being transferred to the Crown Court. Section 18 Assault, on the other hand, can only ever be dealt with in the Crown Court, and can result in a maximum sentence of life imprisonment, although sentences of more than 10 years for Section 18 are rare.
Section 47 Assault - Actual Bodily Harm (ABH)
This is assault resulting in harm such as scratches, bruises etc. The only intention required is to want to assault the victim, which means to exert unlawful force. So, for example, if a defendant has attempted to throw beer on another person, but the glass slips and hits the person, then even though there has been no intention to commit ABH, because the intention to throw beer on the victim is enough to make out the offence.
The maximum sentence for ABH is 5 years, and this offence can be dealt with in the Magistrates Court. In reality, defendants will rarely receive sentences anywhere near 5 years for this offence unless the attack, and defendants with no previous convictions will often not receive prison sentences.
Section 39 Assault Common Assault
This offence is committed when someone either applies unlawful force on another person (for example by hitting or slapping), or makes them afraid that immediate force will be used against them (for example by waving a hand or fist closely at another person). There need not be any marks or injury. Any injury or bruising would usually result in the charge being raised to one of ABH. A first offence usually means a fine or possibly a community penalty, but not usually custody, unless there are features which make the incident more serious, such as other offences, or any allegations of racist behaviour or motivation.
Defences to Offences of Violence
There are certain defences which are often applicable to offences of violence, depending on the facts of the case. Please see the paragraph on defences in our Brief Guide to Criminal Law on the left of this screen.
Strategy in Assault Cases
In assault cases, issues which often arise include the following:
- Forensics / medical evidence - are any injuries consistent with the allegations or do they go against them? - Issues of mistaken identity - Is self-defence available to the defendant
If you are charged or have been arrested for assault, please do contact us for a chat. We have represented clients for assault charges all over England and Wales, and will happily advise clients on issues from GBH to a common assault.